Many fertilisers contain non–food-grade preservatives that most growers don’t even know they’re using.
You might not be eating your fertiliser, but the preservatives inside it absolutely can end up:
- On your crops
- Inside plant tissues
- On produce intended to be eaten, smoked, or brewed
So today’s blog uncovers the preservatives you should avoid, why they’re used in the first place, and how to choose safer alternatives.
Why Preservatives Are Needed—But Why It Matters Which Ones You Use
Any fertiliser or biostimulant containing organic content—seaweed, plant extracts, amino acids, sugars—will grow microbes if left unpreserved, just like a food product would.
So yes, preservatives are necessary.
But there’s a significant difference between:
- Food-grade preservatives, which are safe for contact with consumable crops
- Industrial preservatives, which are intended for patio cleaner, wallpaper paste, and disinfectants—not your tomatoes
At Eutrema, we use only food-grade preservatives for two reasons:
1. Crop safety and consumer exposure
Whatever goes into your fertiliser can end up on your produce.
2. Microbial compatibility
Excessively strong preservatives don’t just kill the “bad guys”—they also kill the beneficial microbes growers want to introduce into their growing media.
Yet many fertiliser companies still use industrial or cosmetic-grade preservatives simply because they are cheap, powerful, and convenient.
Let’s look at the worst offenders.
The “Dirty Dozen”: Preservatives Growers Should Avoid
1. Formaldehyde / Formalin — The Worst of the Worst
Carcinogenic. Hazardous. Used in livestock disinfectants.
Shockingly, some fertiliser and seaweed extract products have used it.
I once tested an “organic” seaweed extract preserved with formaldehyde and suffered a severe skin reaction. That manufacturer is now out of business—rightly so.
Avoid completely.
Should never appear in anything that touches consumable crops.
2. Quats (Quaternary Ammonium Compounds)
Common example: Benzalkonium chloride
These are found in:
- Patio cleaners
- Mould removers
- Wallpaper paste
- Industrial disinfectants
They are:
- Persistent (non-biodegradable)
- Toxic to aquatic life
- Irritating to skin
- Banned in many cosmetics
- Completely unacceptable on food crops
Any fertiliser containing quats should be avoided outright.
3. Copper Sulfate
A heavy metal and moderately toxic.
While allowed in some organic systems in very controlled amounts, long-term exposure can cause health issues for both plants and people. Vineyard workers often experience copper toxicity.
It should never be your first choice as a preservative.
4. Bronopol
Contains bromine and can release formaldehyde.
Also forms nitrosamines—known carcinogens.
Not allowed in food or cosmetics, and should not be in fertilisers.
5. Kathon (MI/MCI)
A powerful sensitiser linked to:
- Allergic reactions
- Dermatitis
- Skin burns at high concentrations
Banned or heavily restricted in cosmetics.
Shouldn’t be anywhere near consumable crops.
6. Silver Nitrate
Used in some disinfectants and occasionally in plant hormone manipulation (e.g., feminising sprays in cannabis).
But silver interferes with ethylene, the key plant hormone. Misuse can cause:
- Leaf drop
- Hormonal disruption
- Sex reversal in plants
It is also residual—it doesn’t break down.
Best avoided entirely in fertilisers.
Why Companies Use These Questionable Preservatives
Often, it comes down to poor planning.
A company finalises a formulation, bottles it, and only then discovers:
- It ferments
- It blows up with gas
- It spoils
- It separates due to microbial growth
At that stage, instead of reformulating with safe ingredients, they reach for strong industrial preservatives that can survive high or low pH.
This “afterthought” approach leads to unsafe inputs being added simply for convenience—or cost-cutting.
Why Not Use Peroxide or Chlorine Instead?
Because they don’t last.
- Hydrogen peroxide breaks down rapidly into water and oxygen
- Chlorine breaks down into chlorine gas
Great for cleaning a hydroponic system.
Terrible for preserving a bottle of fertiliser for months on a shelf.
So What Should Growers Do?
✔ Read the label and Safety Data Sheet
Especially sections listing preservatives or additives.
✔ Search any unfamiliar preservative in ChatGPT
Ask:
“Is this safe to consume or use on food crops?”
✔ Choose fertilisers made with food-grade preservation only
This protects:
- Your crop
- Your consumers
- Your beneficial microbes
- Your own skin and lungs
At Eutrema, products like Gold Leaf / Liquid Gold use only the same types of preservatives you would find in processed foods—not industrial chemicals.
Final Thoughts
Preservatives are necessary—but not all preservatives belong anywhere near plants grown for consumption. Growers deserve transparency and safer formulation options.
If you have a fertiliser preservative you’d like me to review, send it over—I’ll happily cover it in a future episode or blog post.
Article by Dr Russell Sharp
If you would like to keep up to date with subjects just like this, you can listen to both our podcasts! Links can be found bellow:
Hydroponics Daily Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/hydroponics-daily/id1788172771
Cereal Killers Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/cereal-killers/id1695783663